The right to fair justice

The justice system should be fair for everyone.

The right to a fair trial is a fundamental human right and a critical element of a fair justice system. Ensuring a fair trial is not limited to what happens in a court room. Many cases never go to court. In cases that do, the stages that came before court can be just as important. 

Unreliable evidence presents a significant risk to achieving a fair trial. Its use can result in innocent people being convicted (a miscarriage of justice). Such convictions may, or may not, be quashed on appeal.

Courts have wide powers to exclude evidence where they believe it would have an adverse impact on fairness. Courts can also direct a jury to be cautious about convicting a person the basis of certain evidence. Where unreliable evidence is identified, prosecutions may fail.

Both miscarriages of justice and failed prosecutions involve significant unnecessary expense and wasted time, inconvenience witnesses, distress victims and reduce public confidence in the system. 

In order to reduce the risk that evidence is unreliable (and may therefore be excluded), the police are expected to collect evidence in certain ways.

on Friday December 08 by chrisbath
Was this helpful?

The circumstances which render courts likely to exclude evidence are: -

  • breaches of human rights; or
  • breaches of the Police & Criminal Evidence Act 1984 and statutory Codes of Practice; or
  • where the police act in bad faith (acting in good faith does not excuse breaches).
on Friday December 08 by chrisbath
Was this helpful?
In 1972, a man called Maxwell Confait was murdered. Two children and a man with an intellectual disability were arrested and, based on their confessions, convicted. Several years later, forensic evidence showed that they were innocent. Their confessions had been false and were the combined result of their vulnerability and their treatment by police during detention and questioning.
Public concern over the Maxwell Confait case in 1972 led Parliament, via a public inquiry and then a Royal Commission, to pass the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 and its Codes of Practice (PACE).  
PACE set out the rules and safeguards for policing in England and Wales including role of the appropriate adult (AA). The principal intention was to reduce the risk of miscarriages of justice as a result of evidence being obtained from vulnerable suspects which, by virtue of their vulnerability, led to unsafe and unjust convictions
on Friday December 08 by chrisbath
Was this helpful?
Download Free Designs Free Websites Templates

This website uses cookies to manage authentication, navigation, and other functions. By using our website, you agree that we can place these types of cookies on your device.

View Privacy Policy

You have declined cookies. This decision can be reversed.

You have allowed cookies to be placed on your computer. This decision can be reversed.